VideoReDo vs SolveigMM Video Splitter

Video editing doesn’t always require complex timelines and advanced effects. When it comes to precisely editing video, particularly for tasks like removing commercials, trimming unwanted footage, or creating shorter clips, having the right tool is crucial. For quick and precise tasks like cutting, trimming, and joining video files, VideoReDo and SolveigMM Video Splitter offer streamlined solutions. This article compares their lossless editing capabilities, user interfaces, supported formats, and other important features to help you choose the right tool for maintaining video quality while efficiently editing your footage. This article also dives deep into a head-to-head comparison of their features, ease of use, performance, and pricing to help you decide which video editor best suits your needs.

VideoReDo

Picture 1 – VideoReDo interface

VideoReDo TVSuite empowers you to effortlessly edit your video files, regardless of their source. Whether you’re capturing over-the-air broadcasts, converting analog VHS tapes, working with HDTV, DigitalTV, DVB, TiVo, ReplayTV, DVR-MS/WTV files, or extracting chapters from DVDs, VideoReDo offers a comprehensive suite of tools to streamline your workflow.

Main Features:

• Fast Trimming, Cutting, and Joining: Quickly and efficiently trim, cut, and join MPEG1/MPEG compressed digital images.
• MPEG Stream Repair/Fixing: Repair and fix corrupted MPEG streams to ensure smooth playback.
• File Conversion: Convert video files to DVR-MS and WTV formats.
• DVD Authoring (TVSuite/H264 Version): Author DVDs directly from your edited video files.
• H264/AVC Support (TVSuite/H264 Version): Seamlessly edit H264/AVC/MTS/M2TS/AVCHD/MP4/MKV files.
• ProRes, MXF, and DNXHD Support (VideoReDo Pro): Enables editing of professional-grade video formats like ProRes, MXF, and DNXHD.
• Advanced Audio Support (VideoReDo Pro): Handle AES audio, VANC data, and Industry-compliant LKFS normalization.

Important Note: It’s worth noting that development of VideoReDo has stopped, so new features and support for emerging formats are unlikely.

Pros of VideoReDo:

• Lossless Editing: Preserves original video quality by avoiding re-encoding during trimming, cutting, and joining.
• Fast Processing: Efficiently handles MPEG and H.264 files for quick editing workflows.
• Precise Cutting: Offers accurate frame-level editing for clean and professional-looking cuts.
• Easy Commercial Removal: Designed specifically for quickly removing commercials from recorded TV programs.
• User-Friendly Interface: Simple and intuitive interface makes it easy to learn and use, even for beginners.
• Transport Stream (TS) Support: Excellent support for Transport Stream files commonly used in broadcast recordings.
• Commercial Detection Features: Automated commercial detection can help speed up the editing process.
• Batch Processing: Can automate some tasks with the batch processing capabilities.
• DVD Authoring (in Select Versions): Certain versions of VideoReDo can author DVDs directly from your edited files.
• Lightweight and Efficient: Doesn’t require extensive system resources, making it suitable for older computers.
• Quick Ad Scan: This feature allows the user to quickly find and delete the commercials from a video.

Cons of VideoReDo:

• Discontinued Development: Active development has ceased, meaning no new features, updates, or support for emerging formats are being added.
• Limited Format Support: Primarily focused on MPEG and H.264 files. Lacks robust support for other modern video formats like HEVC (H.265) or AV1.
• Outdated Interface: The user interface can feel dated compared to more modern video editors.
• Lacks Advanced Features: Does not offer the advanced editing capabilities found in full-fledged video editing suites (e.g., color correction, motion graphics, complex audio editing).
• No Native Mac Version: Primarily a Windows application; running it on macOS requires workarounds like virtualization.
• This is a paid software, but no way to purchase it: Requires a purchase, but there is no way to purchase this application anymore. So it is available for those who already have the license key.
• Potential Compatibility Issues: With discontinued development, compatibility with the latest operating systems and codecs may become an issue over time.
• DVD Authoring Limitations: The DVD authoring capabilities, present in some versions, are basic compared to dedicated DVD authoring software.
• Limited Audio Editing: Audio editing capabilities are fairly basic.
• Difficult to Find Support: Since development has stopped, it will be harder to find help.

Use cases of VideoReDo:

Here are some specific situations where VideoReDo proves to be a valuable asset:

• Cutting Commercials from TiVo Recordings: Efficiently removing commercials from recordings made with a TiVo DVR.
• Preparing Video for Online Sharing: Quickly trimming unwanted content from a video before uploading it to YouTube or other platforms.
• Creating Highlight Reels: Assembling highlight reels from longer video recordings by cutting out and joining the best moments.
•  Archiving TV Shows: Cleaning up TV show recordings by removing commercials and unwanted segments before archiving them.
• Cleaning up Home Videos: Cleaning videos that are transferred from a VHS to a digital format.

VideoReDo free download is available here.

SolveigMM Video Splitter

Picture 2 – Video Splitter interface

SolveigMM Video Splitter is a powerful yet user-friendly software designed for lossless editing of video files. Whether you need to trim unwanted sections, create smaller clips from a larger video, or join multiple videos together, Video Splitter offers a streamlined solution that preserves the original quality of your media. Its intuitive interface allows you to quickly and accurately mark segments for removal or joining, making the editing process efficient and straightforward, even for novice users.

Unlike traditional video editing software that requires re-encoding, SolveigMM Video Splitter operates in a lossless mode for many popular formats. This means your videos are edited without any degradation in quality, resulting in professional-looking results without the lengthy processing times. Support for a wide range of file formats, including AVI, MP4, MOV, MKV, WEBM, and more, makes it a versatile tool for handling various video editing tasks. Whether you’re creating content for YouTube, archiving personal videos, or preparing files for professional use, SolveigMM Video Splitter provides a fast, reliable, and lossless way to achieve your editing goals.

Main features of SolveigMM Video Splitter

• • Lossless Cutting: Quickly and accurately trim video files without any re-encoding. This means your video quality remains exactly the same, and the process is incredibly fast, preserving every detail.
  • Versatile File Support: Handles a wide range of popular video and audio formats, including MP4, MOV, AVI, MKV, FLV, WEBM, MP3, AAC, and more. This ensures you can work with almost any media file you have.
    • Supported formats are: MXF, AVCHD, MP4, MOV, MKV, WEBM, FLV, AVI, DV AVI, ASF, WMV, MPEG2(TS, PS, VES), MPEG1(SYS, VES), MP1, MP2, MP3, WAV.
    • Supported codecs are: H265/HEVC, H264/AVC, MPEG-1, MPEG-2, VP8, VP9, MPEG-4, DIVX, XVID, MJPEG, WMV1, WMV2, WMV3, MPEG Audio, PCM, AC3, AAC, OPUS.
  • High-Speed Video Editing: Experience lightning-fast video editing thanks to its efficient, lossless cutting technology. Get your editing tasks done in a fraction of the time compared to traditional, re-encoding splitters.
  • Intuitive User Interface: Easily navigate and use the software with its user-friendly design. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced editor, you’ll find it simple to get started and perform your tasks quickly.
  • Reliable Performance: Trust in a stable and dependable tool for your video splitting needs. The software is built for efficiency and accuracy, ensuring consistent results.
  • Batch Processing: Efficiently cut multiple video files simultaneously. Save significant time by processing several videos at once, ideal for handling large projects or numerous files. Supported in the Business and Broadcast Editions.
• Easy files joining of all supported formats
• Supports files of high resolution. 4K files support in the Home Edition and other plans is already available.
• Different video preview options: 
  • Compare video mode for preview: play two files simultaneously. Convenient if you need to compare two frames or quality of files.
  •  Zoom preview: convenient if you need to see some small details on the video
• Convenient if you need to use it on your several computers: one license key can be used to register the product on up to 5 different computers. You can use one Video Splitter at the same time.

Pros of Video Splitter

• Precision Editing & Workflow Efficiency:

Edit with frame-accurate precision across all supported file formats, ensuring your output segments precisely match your selections.

Streamline your workflow with:

• Join Manager: Effortlessly merge files and save/load your merge lists.
• Timeline Editing: Place several files on the timeline and edit fragments from various files together on a single timeline.
• Integrated Time Calculator: Keep track of your editing durations.
• Batch Manager (Business & Broadcast Editions): Edit multiple files simultaneously for maximum efficiency.

Additional Features:

• Displays embedded GPS navigation data.
• Zoom in on preview for detailed visual inspection.
• Compare Video Mode (Business & Broadcast Editions): Facilitates side-by-side comparisons.
• Compatible with Windows 7, 8, 10, and 11.

Cons of Video Splitter:

• While there is no Linux version at this time, Video Splitter is available for both Windows and macOS.
• This is a paid product, starting at $7.49/month. You can try the Free Edition before purchasing.

Use cases of Video Splitter

• Lossless & Accurate Editing: Precisely cut unwanted segments from any video or audio file, preserving original quality.
• Versatile Applications:
  • Personal: Edit home videos, create shareable clips.
  • Professional: Prepare content for clients, colleagues, education, presentations, study projects, and more.
• Content Enhancement:
  • Remove TV commercials, censor sensitive scenes (child-friendly content), and mute foul language.
• File Size Reduction:
  • Save computer storage by trimming large files.
  • Optimize videos for social media uploads (YouTube, Facebook, LinkedIn, etc.) by reducing file size.
• Audio Editing:
  • Create personalized phone ringtones.
  • Edit audio podcasts for improved clarity.
• Business Communications:
  • Edit web conferences for efficient sharing.
  • Refine screen recordings for future use.
• Batch Processing (Business & Broadcast Versions):
  • Process entire lists of video files in a single pass with the Batch Manager, ideal for large-scale projects.

Your choice of tool should align with your specific needs. If your goal is primarily to manage storage space or archive large video files, and exact frame precision is not a priority, VideoReDo is an excellent option.

For those requiring meticulous, frame-by-frame editing, SolveigMM Video Splitter is the recommended solution.

Get SolveigMM Video Splitter today.

VideoReDo vs SolveigMM Video Splitter performance comparison

To assess tool performance, we ran several tests on two files.

Their specifications are listed below:

Test file #1: MP4, 1920x1080px@25fps, 30s, 12 Mb/s AVC video (FullHD)

Test file #2: MP4, 3840x2160px@25fps, 30s, 25 Mb/s AVC video (4K)

The tests involved frame-accurate trimming intervals from both files. To minimize the impact of file reading and writing, all tests were executed on an SSD.

Test #1: save one interval from the middle of the original test file

In the first test we will save one interval with a time position (00:00:06.06-00:00:14.00) from the middle of the file with both products.

You will see below what the interfaces of VideoReDo and Video Splitter look like.

Picture 3 – Interface of VideoReDo TVSuite V6: saving one interval in the middle of the file

Picture 4 – Interface of Video Splitter: saving one interval in the middle of the file

Test #2: save two intervals from the middle of the original test file (00:00:06.06-00:00:14.00 & 00:00:18.00-00:00:24.05)

Now, in the second test we will save two intervals in the middle of the original file into the single output file.

The segments will have such time start/end positions:

(00:00:06.06-00:00:14.00 & 00:00:18.00-00:00:24.05)

Picture 5 – Interface of VideoReDo TVSuite V6: saving two intervals in the middle of the file

Picture 6 – Interface of Video Splitter: saving two intervals in the middle of the file

Test #3: join each test file with the same file

In the third test we will join each test file with the same file.

Picture 7 – Interface of VideoReDo TVSuite V6: files joining

Picture 8 – Interface of Video Splitter: files joining

During the tests, we measured each application’s operation time and maximum RAM usage.

• Maximum Memory Utilization (MB): Indicates peak RAM usage in megabytes. Lower values suggest more efficient memory management.
• Operation Time (seconds): Shows the duration in seconds for a specific task (e.g., saving a file). Shorter times denote faster performance and a more responsive experience.

Our findings are as follows:

Table 1 – Comparison of maximum memory utilization (MB) for test#1, test#2, test#3

Table 2 – Comparison of operation time (seconds) for test#1, test#2 and test#3

From the all test results we can see that for both FullHD and 4K in all tests Video Splitter requires less memory utilization then the VideoReDo, Video Splitter was also more efficient than VideoReDo, especially in the test#3 while joining operations.

User experience of VideoReDo and SolveigMM Video Splitter: interface design, ease of use

VideoReDo interface

You can see VideoReDo interface on Picture 1. It is designed with a clear focus on providing a user-friendly experience, particularly for those who need to perform efficient and precise video editing tasks without a steep learning curve. Its interface strikes a balance between offering powerful functionality and maintaining a high degree of simplicity.

VideoReDo’s interface is typically characterized by a traditional, functional layout that prioritizes accessibility. You’ll usually find a main viewing window where your video is displayed, flanked by distinct panels for controls, file management, and editing timelines. This arrangement is familiar to users of many video editing applications, making the transition to VideoReDo relatively smooth.

Key design elements include:

• Clear Button Layout: Important functions like “Cut,” “Join,” “Trim,” and “Save” are usually presented with distinct icons or clear text labels, making them easy to locate and understand.
• Intuitive Timeline: The editing timeline is designed for straightforward manipulation. Users can easily select segments, zoom in for precision, and visually track their edits.
• Tool Panel Organization: Tools and options are logically grouped, preventing clutter and allowing users to find the specific function they need without excessive searching.
• Status and Progress Indicators: The interface provides clear feedback on ongoing processes, such as file loading, encoding, or saving, so users are always aware of what’s happening.

In essence, VideoReDo’s interface is designed to be functional, uncluttered, and intuitive.

Video Splitter interface

SolveigMM Video Splitter is depicted on Picture 2 and is engineered to provide a highly efficient and user-friendly experience, particularly for tasks involving quick, precise cutting and merging of video and audio files. Its interface is deliberately designed to be intuitive, enabling users to achieve their goals with minimal fuss, whether they are beginners or experienced editors.

The interface of SolveigMM Video Splitter is characterized by a clean, logical, and functional layout. It avoids unnecessary complexity, presenting users with the essential tools and controls in an easily accessible manner.

Key design elements include:

• Clear Preview Window: A prominent central area displays the video being edited, allowing users to easily preview and select frames.
• Intuitive Timeline Navigation: The timeline is designed for straightforward manipulation. Users can easily zoom in for frame-accurate selection, mark start and end points for cuts, and see their edits visually represented.
• Well-Organized Tool Panels: Control buttons for cutting, joining, saving, and other core functions are clearly labeled and logically placed, often grouped together for quick access.
• Batch and Join Manager Integration: For users of the Business and Broadcast versions, features like the Batch Manager and Join Manager are seamlessly integrated, often accessible through dedicated tabs or windows, maintaining the overall uncluttered feel of the main interface.
• Format and Settings Display: Information about the current file’s format and relevant settings is usually visible, providing helpful context without being intrusive.

SolveigMM Video Splitter excels in its ease of use, a core aspect of its user experience. The software is built to streamline the editing process, making it accessible for a wide range of users.

In addition to the main window there are Join Manager (in all Editions), and Batch Manager (in Business and Broadcast Editions) windows that you can see below.

Join Manager window of Video Splitter

Batch Manager window of Video Splitter

Feature comparison of VideoReDo and SolveigMM Video Splitter

Key Takeaways:

• VideoReDo is often the go-to choice for users specifically dealing with MPEG-TS and MPEG-PS files, especially for tasks like commercial removal from recorded TV. Its interface is geared towards these specialized workflows.
• SolveigMM Video Splitter stands out for its broad format support, extremely fast lossless editing, intuitive interface, and versatile applications. It’s an excellent general-purpose tool for quickly trimming, cutting, and joining a wide range of video and audio files without quality loss.

Comparative Summary: VideoReDo vs. SolveigMM Video Splitter

When choosing between VideoReDo and SolveigMM Video Splitter, the decision hinges on your specific needs and the types of video files you primarily work with. Both are powerful tools for precise video editing, but they cater to slightly different use cases and offer distinct advantages.

VideoReDo: The Specialist for Broadcast & Recorded Video

VideoReDo has carved out a strong niche, particularly for users who deal with MPEG-TS and MPEG-PS stream formats, commonly found in recorded television content. Its standout feature is its highly effective commercial removal capability, allowing users to quickly and accurately trim out advertisements from recordings with minimal quality loss.

• Strengths:
  • Unmatched Commercial Removal: For cleaning up recorded TV, VideoReDo is often considered the industry standard.
  • Precise Editing on Supported Formats: Excels at frame-accurate cutting and joining for its core supported stream types.
  • Functional and Task-Oriented Interface: Designed for efficiency in its specific domain.

• Considerations:
  • Limited Format Support: Its strength lies in MPEG formats; support for a wider array of modern video codecs (like MP4, MKV, MOV) might be less comprehensive or require plugins.
  • Interface Style: While functional, its interface may appear more traditional or less modern compared to some competitors.

SolveigMM Video Splitter: The Versatile All-Rounder

SolveigMM Video Splitter positions itself as a highly versatile tool that excels in lossless editing across a vast range of video and audio formats. Its primary advantage lies in its speed and the preservation of original quality, making it ideal for quick cuts, mergers, and modifications without re-encoding.

• Strengths:

• • Extensive Format Compatibility: Seamlessly handles MP4, MOV, AVI, MKV, and many more, making it suitable for almost any video file.
  • Exceptional Speed (Lossless): Edits are near-instantaneous, drastically improving workflow efficiency.
  • Frame-Accurate Precision: Guarantees precise cuts and edits for all supported formats.
  • Intuitive and Modern Interface: Designed for ease of use, making it accessible to both beginners and experienced editors.
  • Advanced Features: Offers features like Batch Processing and an integrated Join Manager for enhanced productivity.
  • Subscription Model, Lifetime license and Free Edition: Accessible through a flexible subscription, or lifetime license, with a free demo version available for basic use.

• Considerations:
  • General-Purpose Editing: While it can remove commercials, it might not offer the same specialized, one-click “commercial detection” that VideoReDo provides for TV recordings.

The Verdict:

• Choose VideoReDo if: Your primary need is to edit recorded television content, specifically removing commercials from MPEG-TS/MPEG-PS files, and you prioritize specialized tools for this task.
• Choose SolveigMM Video Splitter if: You work with a wide variety of video and audio formats, need fast and frame-accurate editing without quality loss, require efficient batch processing, or prefer a modern, intuitive interface. It’s the more flexible and broadly applicable solution for general video editing needs.

Both tools offer robust solutions for their respective strengths, making the “better” choice entirely dependent on the specific requirements of your video editing workflow.